This will be because you need to enable an SSL certificate on your custom domain. We take care of this for you but you'll have to click a button. Here's what to do:
- Head to Settings > Domains
- Click the Request HTTPS button next to Secure connection (HTTPS)

- If this is successful the status will change from Off to On. We'll now apply the SSL to your domain automatically and the error will be gone ✨
If you're still having an issue check your custom domain is set up correctly